In 1964 few Italians owned their own TV sets. This was one of the reasons why A Fistful of Dollars, which had been released in the fall of '64, did so well. This sudden success of Fistful at the box-office surprised both audiences and the film's producers alike. The State-run broadcaster RAI TV, had yet to start showing Rawhide, dubbed into Italian under the title 'Gli Uomini della Prateria / The Prairie Men'. That didn't occur until around 1967. Still, audiences wanted more of Clint Eastwood.
A second film, if it got made, was still a year away. Then all hell broke loose. Egos were bruised.
Most of 1965 saw the two-feuding groups of ex-friends
(Fistful's toppers Arrigo Colombo & Giorgio Papi and director Sergio
Leone), suing each other, as well as being sued by Akira Kurosawa and Toho
Films of Japan, over their unauthorized plundering of Yojimbo (1961). Colombo
& Papi even had the audacity to try and sue Eastwood, for doing the second
film, without their permission, which they claimed he needed. They said his
contract with them extended to any sequels. The Italian office of the powerful
William Morris agency, which handled Eastwood worldwide, settled that case in
quick order. These misgiving held up the Fistful's release in most countries
outside Europe (including North America) until late 1966.
During the Summer of 1966, Jolly Films, the original producers behind A Fistful of Dollars, lawfully purchased two TV segments, made years apart, of the recently cancelled US tv series Rawhide (1959-1965) from CBS TV. They then set about preparing their 'new' Clint Eastwood film unaware of the brewing storm this would cause. 'Jolly' of course had been shut out of the A Fistful of Dollars direct sequel, For a Few Dollars More (December 1965), and the third film in the series, The Good, The Bad and The Ugly (December 1966), which was still before cameras at the time, and wanted retribution.
'Jolly' then set out to make their own sequel by using the Rawhide episodes, and, craftily choose Il Magnifico Straniero, which had been the shooting title of A Fistful of Dollars, for the title for their follow-up.
One can envision 'Jolly' cranking out additional 'new' Rawhide/Eastwood oaters for the next few years to come.
The ruse paid off and Straniero bested such local far as Arizona Colt, Brute and the Beast, A Taste of Killing and Yankee (all August releases that would have been slowing down by October), on its opening sprint. Still, the new Straniero served up 'Boffo' returns as Variety put it. At first audiences were probably thrilled at the prospect of a new western starring 'the Man with the Green Eyes', as he was called in Italy. They most likely quickly caught on to the deception, stopped repeat visits, and caused the box-office coffers to dry up.
Legend has it that Eastwood, who was still on the
Continent, making his third oater, The Good, The Bad and The Ugly, took offence
and sued his old employers, and won.
One can see from the Anica page for The Magnificent Stranger (August 11, 1966, for an October release), that the Eastwood character's name had not been changed from 'Rowdy Yates'. Oddly one would have thought that 'Jolly' and their dubbers would have just called him 'Il Straniero', to firm up that the film was a sequel to A Fistful of Dollars, and also add to the fun.
The attached Anica page would have been typed up prior to the film's release and may not have actually reflected the character's final moniker.
The lag between the Anica date, and the release (three months), was probably when the Italo dubbing had been done, andthe character's name could have easily been changed to 'Straniero' to complete the process.
All in all, The Magnificent Stranger was sold off to such counties as Argentina, Brazil, Germany, Greece and Spain, before it was withdrawn.
A year later a second 'new' Clint Eastwood film, El Gringhero (June,1967, sometimes transliterated to 'Gringohero'), was announced. It was touted in the local press and garnered interest, causing eyebrows to arch.
Industry wags got word to Eastwood that another Rawhide movie was in the works, and again he was none too pleased.
This time Eastwood did manage to have the film stopped.
Eastwood took out trade ads denouncing the film and argued that he had never worked for 'Lucas Films of Rome' or for Clarence Brown, an actual American director, who had retired before Rawhide had even started production. The courts agreed and the film disappeared out of sight. Multiple searches for El Gringhero, have yet to turn up any visual evidence of this follow-up Rawhide compilation. It mostly never got past the planning stage.
The title, Gringhero, on the other hand was later used for a Mexican western Un Dolado de Pancho Villa aka 'A Faithful Soldier of Pancho Villa' that was marketed as Mexico amore e sangue per un Gringhero / 'Mexico, Love and Blood for a Gringhero' (June 1968), for its Italian release by Magna Films.
Still later, two official Rawhide movies turned up on Canadian TV (CBC) around 1970-71, Incident at Dead Horse & Incident on Damon's Road, that took full advantage of Eastwood's newfound popularity.
These two English language films were made using actual
two-part episodes, that easily fit together, that solved The Magnificent
Stranger's central problem. One would think that they would have sent out still
sets and ad slicks for both titles. They never resurfaced during the age of
video. It's a wonder that CBS didn't put the two Rawhide movies out on North
American DVD together. Perhaps they figured that they shouldn't wrangle with
By Mike Ferguson