“A Prayer for the Dying” Review: Johnny Flynn and John
C. Reilly Anchor an Impressively Severe End-of-Days Western
The frontier resilience of a small Wisconsin settler
town is steadily overpowered by a deadly epidemic in Dara Van Dusen's tough,
taut debut.
Variety
By Guy Lodge
February 13, 2026
The rolling grasslands of Slovakia stand in for the
plains of 19th-century Wisconsin in “A Prayer for the Dying,” though the
spiritual setting of Dara Van Dusen‘s unforgiving western lies in some remote
outpost between anywhere and nowhere. As a small rural settlement is swiftly
and ruthlessly stripped bare by the twin plagues of a diphtheria epidemic and
spreading wildfires, the film eventually descends into a near-literal
hellscape, though even when pandemonium takes over on screen, Van Dusen’s
formal control never wavers. The starriest prospect in Berlin’s Perspectives
competition for first features, it’s an imposing, ascetic debut, braced by
performances of formidable grit and commitment from Johnny Flynn and John C.
Reilly.
A native New Yorker now based in Norway, Van Dusen duly
brings a blend of ruggedly American and Euro-arthouse sensibilities to a story
with a burnt whiff of Cormac McCarthy to it — though it’s in fact adapted from
a 1999 work of historical fiction by Stewart O’Nan that looks rather prescient
from a 21st-century vantage point. It’s hard not to view this parable of a
public health crisis exacerbated by misinformation and environmental disaster
through a post-COVID lens. That lends contemporary urgency to a starkly
authentic period piece, while also making it a potentially hard sell to
audiences leery of end-of-days pandemic visions. Either way, it promises yet
bigger things from its sternly focused writer-director.
It begins in an infernal blanket of orange haze,
introducing grimy, wild-eyed Jacob Hansen (Flynn) as he points a rifle at the
blurry, burning world around him — while the camera glides through the haze
with the eerie, disembodied quality of a first-person shooter game. A title
card specifies the year as 1870, a few years after the end of the Civil War,
but can that be right? Everything on screen suggests the world has met its
maker.
We rewind a short time. The skies clear, the land no
longer ablaze but still a dry, flammable golden. Jacob, fresher-faced and
better kempt, is an intrepid Norwegian settler and Civil War veteran in the new
frontier town of Friendship, Wisconsin, where he lives with his wife Marta
(Kristine Kujath Thorp) and their newborn daughter. Theirs is a community so
small that Jacob does triple duty as its sheriff, preacher and undertaker,
roles that circumstances will shortly consolidate in unhappy fashion. He’s spared
the job of village doctor, at least: That goes to Guterson (Reilly), a kindly
pragmatist equally unprepared for the gathering storm.
An agonized woman, writhing and coughing and gnarled by
disease, is found in a field on the edge of town. Guterson diagnoses
diphtheria, relentless and contagious, but tells only Jacob — together, they
hope it’s an isolated case. But “A Prayer for the Dying” announces itself
early, with its sparse, baleful atmospherics, as a tale where hope goes
unrewarded. Though Marta, more pessimistic and proactive than her husband, asks
that they leave straight away, Jacob feels a grim duty of care to the
townspeople, even as he shields them from the direct truth of what they are
facing. The disease spreads. The sky reddens. On the horizon appears a woolly
shroud of smoke from a distant wildfire. It doesn’t stay distant for long.
Lean and terse and driven more by anxiety than incident,
Van Dusen’s script doesn’t go in for surprises or conventionally developing
tension, not least since the film’s prologue has already shown us where it’s
all apocalyptically headed. But it’s a nervy, perceptive examination of the
denial and fatalism toward which even community leaders can be inclined at
moments of inescapable peril — an elemental, even Biblical, variation of the
old horror-film trope that invites the audience’s queasy, helpless resistance
to a character’s most patently self-destructive decisions.
In his punchiest big-screen showcase since 2017’s
“Beast,” Flynn maps Jacob’s interior spiritual collapse with ever more agitated
delivery and progressively winded body language, his stance shifting from that
of a bluff, rugged protector and man of the people to darting, desperate
survivalist. As the town’s man of science and reason, Reilly — an actor who,
following last year’s “Heads or Tails?,” looks and sounds entirely at home in
the realm of surreal period Americana — is a sturdily paternalistic presence
until, suddenly and vulnerably, he isn’t anymore, and a soul-sinking
derangement takes over.
But it’s the film’s below-the-line contributors who
really tighten the screws, beginning with DP Kate McCullough. An ASC Spotlight
nominee for her airy, radiant work on Irish Oscar nominee “The Quiet Girl,” she
works here in a far more cramped, claustrophobic register, using Academy ratio,
a deadwood palette gradually stripped of any verdant possibility, and an
effective tendency toward jumpy whip-pans as the situation worsens.
Jan Kocman’s slow-pulsing score coordinates perfectly
with Gustaf Berger and Jesper Miller’s sound design in its sparseness, the
landscape seeming to creak and echo as it depopulates. Likewise, production
designer Hubert Pouille’s boxy, timber-built structures aptly have a toy-town
quality to them, as if they went up just yesterday, and can be destroyed just
as fast by vengeful natural forces. In “A Prayer for the Dying,” man is mere
kindling.
A Prayer for the
Dying – International title
A 2024 Swedish,
British, Greek, Norwegian co-production [Film i Väst, Garagefilm
International, Tom Wilhelmsens Stiftelse
(Stockholm), Anton, The Bureau (London),
Asterisk, Yafka Studio (Athens), Eye Eye
Pictures, Oslo Pictures, Albert Verlinde
Producties, Talent Norge (Oslo),
Producers: John
Baker, Harald Fagerheim Bugge, Charles Dorfman, Jan Kallista, Tom
Kjeseth, Ketil Lømsland, Marcin Luczaj,
Jan Naszewski, Andrea Berentsen Ottmar,
Sébastien Raybaud, Magnus Thomassen,
Marlon Vogelgesang, Dyveke Bjørkly
Graver, Pavel Bercík, Kristina Börjeson,
Fenia Cossovitsa, Jana Garajova, Tristan
Goligher, Vicky Miha, Mimmi Spång, Zahra
Waldeck
Director: Dara Van
Dusen
Story: A Prayer
for the Dying by Stewart O’Nan
Screenplay: Dara Van
Dusen
Cinematographey:
Kate McCullough [color]
Music: Beata
Hlavenkova
Running time: 95
minutes
Cast:
Jacob Hansen –
Johnny Flynn
Doc – John C. Reilly
Marta Hansen -
Kristine Kujath Thorp
Harlow - Gustav
Lindh
Chase - Hilton
Pelser
Fenton - Andrew
Whipp
Ol Meyer - Daniel
Weyman
Bart - David Ganly
John Henry - Peter
Adame
Sarah Ramsay - Radka
Caldová
Marcus &
Thaddeus - Tobias John Coulton-Shaw
Lydia - Dagmar
Edwards
Train engineer –
Eduard Horvath
Fred Lembeck - Juraj
Hrcka
Cyril - Christopher
John-Slater
Sylvester - Tadhg
Murphy
Bitsi - Nienna
Robinsonová
Emil - Christopher
Rygh
Singing woman -
Monika Stolcova
Amelia - Charlotte
Vorobjov
Chase's
woman/village girl – Vanessa Weisz
Millard - Leonard
Winkler
Dead soldier -
Viktor Zorňan
Stunt coordinator -
Roman Jankovic
Stunts: Marián
Chmelár, Martin Csiaki, Sona Havranova, Milan Hrvol, Denisa Juhos, Matus
Lajcak, Stano Satko (Stanislav Satko), Miroslava Slezáková, Michal Vesely
Trailer
link - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mj_kkJFm4AQ